BLOG FOR SALE SOLD AUCTION GUIDE FOR BROKERS THE BRIEF SELLING IN BANKRUPTCY WEBINARS IN THE MEDIA FAQ ABOUT
Cohen on Real Estate
REAL ESTATE AUCTION INSIGHTS  ·  WITHOUT RESERVE
LINKEDIN  ·  X  ·  YOUTUBE
Need to chat? Schedule now

A hundred years ago, commercial real estate ran on trust and a handshake at the country club. Then technology took over, to the point that most people relied on email and internet marketing and stopped picking up the phone.

Now AI is freeing us up to do what we do best.

Go to the country club!

Picture a meeting in 2030.

You sit down across from an owner with every piece of information at your fingertips. Every sale, lease, mortgage, permit, tenant, comp, capital source and likely buyer. AI has underwritten the building, run the scenarios and flagged the risks. Even his golf handicap is in there.

Then you do what the machine can’t.

You talk over a liquid lunch.

And the deal comes down to the oldest question in the business.

Do I trust you?

The Human Century

For most of its history, commercial real estate was a people business because it had no other choice.

A broker knew the owner. A banker knew the borrower. An investor walked the property, knew the corner, looked the seller in the eye and made a call. Due diligence was a firm handshake and a decent steak.

Information was scarce, underwriting was crude, and decisions came down to experience, instinct and trust.

The law even had a phrase for it. Caveat emptor. Let the buyer beware.

The seller sent over the documents, and it was on you to find what wasn’t true. The environmental problem you couldn’t see. The tenant roster that looked full until after closing, when you discovered every tenant was the seller’s family. Including the brother-in-law who hadn’t paid rent since the Carter administration.

Good information was hard to get. Trust filled the gaps.

Then We Engineered the Uncertainty Out

For decades, we worked to eliminate that uncertainty.

We built databases, spreadsheets, CRMs, listing platforms, AVMs and analytics. Digital deal rooms, satellite imagery, foot traffic data, demographics, transaction histories, rent comps and debt data.

At some point, we had more spreadsheets than tenants and so many connections we barely knew anybody.

Little by little, the fog lifted. Somewhere along the way, the industry became data-rich and relationship-poor.

We spent so long solving the information problem that we half-forgot what the information was for.

We got very good at knowing things. We got worse at deciding.

And now AI promises to finish the job.

What Happens to Trust?

Trust has always performed two jobs.

First, it vouched for the facts. Is the rent roll real? Is the NOI honest? Is the seller telling the truth?

Second, it vouched for intent. Will the buyer actually close? Will the seller honor the agreement? Does the broker have my interests at heart?

We bundled those questions into one gut call because we had no reliable way to separate them.

Now the facts can be checked. You can match leases against payments, reconcile operating statements, trace ownership histories and spot inconsistencies in seconds.

Sorry, rent roll. Nothing personal.

Intent is another story. The machine can verify the leases. It can’t tell you whether the tenants plan to renew, or whether the seller knows something about the neighborhood that hasn’t hit the data yet. It can audit the seller’s documents. It can’t audit your broker’s incentives, or tell you whether his enthusiasm is conviction or commission.

I’ve been a broker for over thirty years. I know that look.

Some of the people you need to trust are supposed to be on your side of the table.

So caveat emptor survives. The buyer still has to beware. Just of the things you can’t look up.

Where the Money Goes

For generations, information asymmetry created enormous opportunities in real estate.

Find a property whose owner doesn’t know the market. Spot what other investors missed. Buy below value because you know something the seller doesn’t.

We called that skill. Sometimes it was. Sometimes it was simply the other side’s ignorance showing up in your returns.

A lot of very nice boats got bought that way.

As information becomes available to everyone, those opportunities shrink.

Clean assets attract more confidence and better pricing. Properties hiding problems get harder to sell. The discount buyers demand for uncertainty narrows as more risks become measurable.

Information arbitrage gets a lot harder.

So where does the value go?

Execution. Can you actually operate, lease and reposition the building?

Forward judgment. Every comp is history. What does the neighborhood become?

Creativity. Can you see a use or structure that others have overlooked?

Cost of capital. Cheap money still beats a clever spreadsheet.

Conviction. When the data is ambiguous, somebody still has to make the call.

When everyone has the same information, the advantage goes to what you do with it.

We’ve Gone Full Spiral

So here we are, apparently back where the business began.

A broker and an owner sitting across a table, discussing a property, deciding whether they trust each other.

It looks like we’ve gone full circle.

I think it’s a spiral.

We return to the same place, one level higher, with a century of technology underneath us.

In 1925, trust stood in for facts we couldn’t get. In 2030, we’ll have nearly every fact on the table before the first handshake.

A century ago, we had judgment and very little data. Then we spent decades building mountains of information, often at the expense of the relationships that made the business work.

Now we get both.

The best brokers, investors and lenders will have every fact in hand and the time to do what made them good in the first place: read people and make the call.

So yes, go to the country club.

Just bring your AI bot to caddie.

Trending